Donizetti Society
Donizetti Picture
pic 
Home button 

 Louise Bertin

Charles Jernigan, July 2023

Charles wrote this short biography in conjunction with his commentary on Bertin's opera, Fausto and
his review of a concert performance of it in Paris in June 2023.

What an interesting composer Louise Bertin (1805-77) is! Crippled in childhood, probably by polio or by a childhood accident, she would not follow the traditional path of a woman of her age—marriage and children. Born not to great wealth nor to the aristocracy, she was nonetheless the child of intelligent parents who were extremely well connected in the artistic world of Paris in the first half of the nineteenth century and who doted on their daughter, offering her avenues for self expression and fulfillment which were certainly unusual for a woman in the early nineteenth century. Trained by Fétis and Anton Reicha, arguably the best music teachers in Paris at the time, Bertin set about a career as a composer at an early age, and wrote her first opera (Guy Mannering after Walter Scott) in 1825 when she was 20. It was privately performed, but in 1827 her first professionally produced work—at the Opéra-Comique—was the one-act Le loup-garou, with a libretto by none other than Eugène Scribe. (It was revived by Opera Southwest in Albuquerque, New Mexico, in September, 2022 and by Gothic Opera in London in November).

pic
pic

In 1829 she began to work on an opera based on Goethe’s Faust, which had recently appeared in a French translation by Gérard de Nerval. Fausto premiered in Paris at the Thèâtre-Italien in 1831 without much success.  Nevertheless, Bertin set to work on a fourth opera which turned out to be her major—and final—work, La Esmeralda, a grand opera with a libretto by Victor Hugo himself, based on his own great novel Notre-Dame de Paris.  La Esmeralda debuted at the Opéra in 1838 and had its modern premiere in Montpellier in 2008 (a performance which was recorded and is available on You Tube).

And then silence. Neither Fausto nor La Esmeralda had enjoyed popular success, and critics questioned whether Bertin’s talent had provided her entree to the three great opera stages of Paris of her time—the Comique, the Italien and the Opéra—or whether her operas were produced because of her family connections and her friendship with major artists of the day, including Berlioz and Hugo. Was she criticized and even ridiculed because she was a woman (and disabled) who dared to seek success in the almost totally male world of opera composition? Or was she an amateur working in a realm which was beyond her abilities?

On June 20, 2023, a modern audience in Paris had another chance to answer those questions when the Palazzetto Bru Zane in collaboration with the Théâtre des Champs-Elysées, the orchestra Les Talens Lyrique and the chorus of Radio Flamande offered a concert performance of Fausto, which had enjoyed only three performances almost 200 years ago before the season ended—and was not revived.

Fausto is a unicum in many ways.  First of all, as far as I can ascertain, it was the first opera to be based on Goethe’s Faust. (Louis Spohr’s 1816 singspiel  Faust was based on the medieval legends, not Goethe’s 1808 verse play, Faust, Part. One.) Gérard de Nerval’s French prose translation of Faust, Part One appeared in 1828-29; almost simultaneously Berlioz composed his Huit Scènes de Faust, his first published work, which would eventually become the nexus of his “dramatic legend” La damnation de Faust in 1845. Bertin seems to have begun work on Fausto at almost the same time and planned it for production at the Théâtre-Italien in 1830, but the production was postponed for a year. To put it into context with other, more famous, operatic settings of Faust, the first version of Gounod’s Faust would not come until 1859, and Boito’s Mefistofele nine years later, in 1868, 37 years after Fausto.

Fausto is also unique in that it was an opera by a French composer to an Italian libretto on a German work then unknown in France. Bertin intended it for the Thèâtre-Italien, which performed works in the Italian language and in the bel canto idiom of the era. Rossini himself was closely associated with the theatre and became its director in October, 1831. The text of Fausto was written first in French by Bertin herself, and translated into Italian by Luigi Balocchi, the house librettist of the Italiens.  In a further bow to Italian formats, Bertin composed her work as an opera semi-seria, which fused elements of comedy into an otherwise serious work.  

Bertin’s work is also unusual of course because she was a woman. She was not the first French woman to write an opera, but it was certainly unusual in 1831, a novelty noted by all of the contemporary critics, who referred to her not by name, but as a "demoiselle".  

It is interesting to note that the postponed 1830 performances of the opera cast the principal role of Fausto as a female singer in travesti, another bow perhaps to Italian operatic tradition. Evidently Rosmunda Pisaroni was to be the mezzo Fausto, but when the premiere was postponed by a year, she was no longer available and Bertin rewrote the role for Domenico Donzelli, a tenor.  For the modern revival, Palazzetto Bru Zane decided to return to the original score and cast a mezzo-soprano, Karine Deshayes, as Fausto. Presumably, this was the first time ever that the original version was heard.