Donizetti Society
Donizetti Picture
Newsletter archives 2014 onwards 
pic

 Verdi's Ernani at Buxton

Buxton Festival, July 4- 21, 2024

Russell Burdekin, July 10, 2024

Photos by Genevieve Girling courtesy of Buxton International Festival

 

The Team

Ernani - Roman Arndt

Don Carlo - Andre Heyboer

Don Ruy Gomez de Silva - Alistair Miles

Elvira - Nadine Benjamin

Giovanna - Jane Burnell

Don Riccardo  - Emyr Lloyd Jones

Jago - Theo Perry

 

Conductor - Adrian Kelly 

Director - Jamie Manton

Movement/Assistant Director - Corina Wuersch

 Designer - Sami Fendall 

Lighting Designer - D M Wood

     

For almost all of the past 45 years the Buxton Festival has continued to stage interesting and usually good quality productions in spite of fluctuating financial fortunes. This year their flagship opera was Verdi’s Ernani premiered in 1844. While in itself hardly top-drawer Verdi, it provides a stream of very listenable music with several numbers pointing to the later, mature Verdi; particularly interesting was Don Carlo’s lament on the hollowness of power that strongly presages Philip’s aria in Verdi’s Don Carlos. The main problem with the opera lies in the libretto with its assumption that someone will kill themselves as the result of a promise once made under duress. This artificial denouement undercuts any sense of real tragedy and isn’t helped by the lack of credibility elsewhere, such as Don Carlos’s ability to recognise the king and the king’s fleeting attraction to Elvira.

Buxton have always struggled with mounting an arresting staging on their limited budget. Oddly, this year’s was a very plain affair but more effective than many they have staged in the past. Essentially, two plain sides narrowed from the front of stage to an opening at the end, presumably indicating the forces of fate slowly closing in.  Doors in the sides enabled entrances and exits; the set up can be see clearly in one of the photos below.  In later scenes a ring of light slowly descended on the protagonists as fate finally trapped them.  The only movable prop was a bed for Elvira which later, when the cover was taken off later, became Charlemagne’s tomb. This lack of scenery and props put more emphasis on the individual acting, which sometimes felt a bit undercooked and lacking direction. The exception was a stylised wedding dance that was quite entertaining and interesting in its way but quite out of keeping with the quasi-realistic tone of the rest of the production. The production wasn’t helped by being vaguely updated to the present day with handguns being waved around while singing about swords, directors seemingly unaware that their lack of physical prominence detracts from the impact of a scene. This updating hardly made the idea of Ernani killing himself as a result of his promise more plausible. Costumes were generally unremarkably modernish apart from Don Silva’s rather fetching blue outfit and a totally awful wedding dress for Elvira.  However, all in all, the staging held up well and in practice helped focus attention on the music

The first thing that struck musically was the power of the opening chorus. Buxton looked to have strengthened what can be one of their weaknesses and the slanting sides of the staging in effect acted as a sort of megaphone that helped to amplify the singing. The principals were all on good form with it being a particular pleasure seeing the veteran Alistair Miles as De Silva and the whole performance was kept moving along well under Artistic Director, Adrian Kelly.

Photos by Genevieve Girling, courtesy of Buxton International Festival

     

pic

Ernani and chorus

 

pic

Elvira

    

pic

De Silva

  

pic

Elvira

 

pic

The king at Charlemagne's tomb

  

pic

The king proclaiming pardons for the conspirators

   

pic

The rather formalised wedding day chorus
This shows the sloping back of the staging and the ring of light that was gradually lowered

    

pic

Elvira and Ernani
The ring of light now trapping Ernani