Donizetti Society
Donizetti Picture
Newsletter archives 2014 onwards 
Home button 

 “THAT ROSSINI COMPANY”
DOES 
LE COMTE ORY

Alberquerque, New Mexico, February 5, 10 &12, 2023

Charles Jernigan, February 2023
(Charles saw the February 10 performance)
 
Photos by Lance W. Ozier

One would not expect to find a sophisticated opera company in the windswept mesas of central New Mexico, but the Land of Enchantment (New Mexico’s official nickname) boasts two. The more famous, Santa Fe Opera, performs a summer season outdoors in a beautiful setting just north of the capital, but feisty Opera Southwest is celebrating its fiftieth anniversary in the state’s largest city, Albuquerque.  Under its Music Director, Anthony Barrese, the company has carved out a special niche by unearthing forgotten nineteenth century works like Franco Faccio’s Amleto and Giovanni Bottesini’s Ali Baba, as well as premiering new works with a southwest flavor like this year’s Zorro by Hector Armienta.  And then there is Rossini.  Opera Southwest has performed more Rossini operas than any other American opera company—eleven to be precise, and counting.  That is not to say that Puccini and Verdi and Wagner are ignored, not at all, but Rossini is Maestro Barrese’s first love, and Albuquerque audiences have had the good fortune of seeing more Rossini in recent years than any other city in America.  Call them Pesaro West (after the festival which takes place annually in the composer’s hometown). Or as The Santa Fe New Mexican nominated them recently, "That Rossini Company".  

This year’s Rossini offering was one of the composer’s best works, Le Comte Ory, an opera full of irony and wit and bawdy humor allied with the most sophisticated and tuneful music that sends you home humming the tunes. Le Comte Ory came as something of a surprise when Rossini premiered it 1828 at the Paris Opera. A comic opera which mocks religious hypocrites and has Ory and his men dressing up as nuns to infiltrate a castle filled with horny young women would never have made it past the conservative forces running the Opèra if the composer had not been Rossini. As for the composer, he had found an ideal vehicle to recycle music from his Italian opera Il viaggio a Reims, an occasional work written for the coronation of the French king, Charles X, which Rossini did not believe would have a shelf life beyond the new king’s assumption of power. There was new music in Ory too, including the most perfect trio Rossini ever wrote—a sort of nocturne-parody which encapsulates all the wit and humor of the situation with suave and luscious melodies: a man dressed as a woman (Ory) is trying to make love to a woman (Countess Adele), but in the dark is really making love to a man (his page, Isolier), a role sung by a woman dressed as a man. Rossini himself no doubt relished the inherent parody of the operatic traditions of his time when it was common to have mezzo-sopranos sing male roles, but he anticipates the complexities of our time when gender roles are not always so fixed and gender bending is a common—and sometimes controversial—occurrence.  

For this production, Maestro Barrese used the critical edition of the score by Damien Colas published in 2014 which includes some music not in the traditional (Troupenas) edition used by most opera companies for the last 200 years (e.g., the Metropolitan in their 2011 production or in the Chicago Lyric Opera production of October, 2022). There are many small differences, but the most notable one occurs in the opera’s finale, now extended by some 60 measures. In the traditional reading, the opera seemed to end too abruptly when the crusaders return home, putting an end to Ory’s attempts to storm the castle of Countess Adele and her ladies. Now, with the new music, along with accurate articulation envisioned by Rossini and the restoration of smaller cuts in several numbers (e.g. the Gouverneur’s aria), the opera has new life.  Barrese also encouraged his singers to choose variations and ornaments which fit their own voices, based on the very extensive possibilities by Rossini and others published in the critical edition. Rossini would certainly have approved. Apparently, this is the first time that the complete opera based on this critical edition has been done in North America.

The ’spa’ at Formoutiers with Adele’s castle on the hill  

The comedy of Le Comte Ory comes from the incongruous juxtaposition of religion and sex, a technique harking back to the fabliaux of the Christian Middle Ages, most famously found in Boccaccio’s Decameron (1348); that is a time period also associated with the semi-legendary figure of Count Ory and the fabliau-like tale of his use of religion to lay siege to the chastity of the Countess Adele and her ladies. The story first appeared in literature in an allegorical fairy tale by Marie-Jeanne L’Héritier de Villandon called “The Discreet Princess, or the Adventures of Finetta,” published in 1696. (L’Héritier was the niece of Charles Perrault, whose fairy tale collections include familiar versions of Cinderella, Bluebeard, Little Red Riding Hood and Sleeping Beauty among many others.)  

What was a moral tale warning of sexual dalliance in L’Héritier became a comic, bawdy tale in versions in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Eugène Scribe and Gaspard Delestre-Poirson turned it into a one act play with music (a vaudeville) in 1816, and twelve years later Scribe turned it into a libretto for Rossini’s opera.  In Act 1, Ory disguises himself as a “holy hermit” come to ‘comfort’ the distressed ladies of Formoutiers, whose menfolk are all off at the crusades. When that doesn’t work, Ory and his men all dress as nuns on a pilgrimage to infiltrate the castle in Act 2. Thus phony “holy” figures use religion to further the satisfaction of their sexual desires, a phenomenon as familiar today as it was in the fourteenth century of Boccaccio.  

Opera Southwest’s production, by Kristen Barrett, brought the action forward from the Middle Ages to the art nouveau period at the beginning of the twentieth century. In Act 1, instead of disguising himself as a hermit, Ory plays the role of a health guru in the manner of John Harvey Kellogg, the inventor of corn flakes, who ran a Sanitarium/hospital at Battle Creek, Michigan, in the early twentieth century. (The 1993 novel The Road to Wellville by T. Coraghessan Boyle and the subsequent comedy-drama film may have been the inspiration of the production.) Formoutiers has become a health spa, perhaps suggested by the spa town of Plombières-les-Bains, the setting for Il viaggio a Reims, the musical sire of  Le Comte Ory.  

“A la faveur de cette nuit obscure”: Sister Collette makes love to Isolier.

In this version Ory uses an ‘exercise’ regimen to exorcise the depression and ennui among the women while suggesting that a love affair (sex) is just the thing to restore health..  Act 2 drops the health fad context and restores the libretto’s original joke when Ory and his men dress as nuns to gain access to the Countess’ castle, although this castle (sets by Dahl Delu) is decorated with paintings of lovely art nouveau damsels.  Barrett directed her singers carefully and individually, and movement and stage action were consistently funny.  The chorus (the men dressed in early twentieth century exercise attire while the women were dressed as lovely Gibson Girls) acted individually too. It was altogether the funniest Comte Ory I have ever seen, with clear motivation and action. The only slightly jarring note in the updating came with anachronistic references to crusaders returning from the wars, while the only scene where the stage action could have used some work was the sexually ambiguous trio, which took place on a Victorian settee in the Countess’ sitting room and sometimes kept the characters at some distance from each other. Most productions set this scene in the Countess’ bedroom and the trio plays out on and around a bed.  

The production was fun, the scenery was clever and amusing (with a castle on a distant hill in Act 1) and the lighting (by Brittany Chato) kept the focus on the principals. Best of all was the singing by several artists who have become favorites in Albuquerque. Christopher Bozeka (Nadir in Opera Southwest’s Ali Baba) led the list as the titular character.  He has a perfect “Rossini” tenor voice, capable of sweet and dulcet tones, including high head notes, accompanied by an easy facility with coloratura and some spectacular full-voiced high notes. He is an excellent actor too. Bozeka will sing the fiendishly difficult role of Rodrigo in Rossini’s Otello in Central City next summer. Tim Mix as the Tutor/Governor had the deep, low notes to match Bozeka’s forays into the stratosphere.  Mix is a young, tall and imposing presence, and for his aria (“Veiller sans cesse”), he dropped to notes which would make Sarastro envious.  Matthew Hanscom sang Raimbaud, Ory’s henchman, with great gusto, mastering the quick parlando of his drinking song “Ah, la bonne folie.”

Christopher Bozeka and Lindsay Ohse  

The women were equally good. Lindsay Ohse is a favorite in Albuquerque, where she has previously sung Norma, Amenaide (Tancredi) and Serpina (La serve padrona). Her silvery high notes and beautiful, rounded tones are matched by her ability to plunge into the depths, and she has a real gift for comedy. Her Adele was less ditzy blonde than frustrated woman who nurses an affection for Ory’s page Isolier, but whatever she was doing, she had a flawless way around the difficult coloratura of the role.  Amanda Crider was also perfect in the comedy surrounding Isolier, with a funny mustache drawn on her lip. Isolier’s Act 1 aria, “Une dame de haut parage” is, however, no joke coloratura-wise, and Crider brought it off with great panache.  I loved the way the production played with her petite frame, as the taller Adele picks her up and swinging her around in the finale.  But Crider’s voice belied the diminutive size of her person; it is big and rich. Laurel Semerdjian added her rich mezzo voice too, as Ragonde, Adele’s lady-in-waiting, or companion in this production. Mary Brzezinski sang Alice.  All in all, this was the best of the operas I have seen in Albuquerque; every role was excitingly sung, the acting was continuously funny with well-nigh perfect comic timing and the stage direction was the best I have seen in this opera (a history which starts for me in the early 1970s at the University of Southern California when I first fell in love with this Rossini work).  

Of course none of it would have been possible without the musical direction of Maestro Barrese, who combines the talents of conductor, impresario and musicologist. The Opera Southwest Orchestra now has eleven Rossini operas under their collective belt—they are familiar with the style. Barrese knows how to build a climax in the irresistible Rossini manner that makes you want to jump out of your seat, and he knows how to trust the singers and give them the space to embellish so that each performance is a little bit different vocally. His use of the critical edition’s extended finale gave us time to see that Adele and Isolier are united—and that Ory is plotting his next futile assault on female virtue. Why on earth other companies, including the Met and even the Rossini Opera Festival in Pesaro would not use this version I do not know—but Barrese did use it.  Just another reason why Opera Southwest is “That Rossini Company.”  

The Nuns find the wine cellar; Matthew Hanscom as Raimbaud  

P.S. After the February 10, Friday night, performance which I saw, the pandemic struck, and by Saturday morning both Adele and Ragonde had succumbed to Covid-19 if not to Ory’s blandishments.  In a frenetic twenty-four hour period Teresa Castillo and Kathryn DeYoung flew in, learned their roles and sang Adele and Ragonde, and saved the Sunday matinee from cancelation. By all accounts they were very well received.