Donizetti Society
Donizetti Picture
Newsletter archives 2014 onwards 
pic

 Bellini's La sonnambula at Buxton

Buxton Festival, July 8- 22, 2023

Russell Burdekin, July 2023

Photos by Genevieve Girling courtesy of Buxton International Festival

 

The Team

Amina - Ziyi Dai

Elvino - Nico Darmanin

Rodolfo - Simon Shibambu 

Lisa - Ellie Neate 

Teresa - Ann Taylor

Alessio - Jacob Bettinelli

 

Conductor - Adrian Kelly 

Director - Harry Fehr  

Assistant Director - Nick Bond

Set Designer - Nicky Shaw 

Costume Designer - Zahra Mansouri 

Lighting Designer - Jake Wiltshire

 

Bellini's La sonnambula is a  tricky opera to bring off well; how to articulate its thin plot, which is far fetched even by operatic standards and peopled with insubstantial, unconvincing, characters in an imagined, idealised, landscape, all kept aloft by gorgeous melodies provided that there are singers willing and able to breath life into it. Given the hurdles and Buxton's slim resources, it was rather courageous of them to take it on and within those constraints to have succeeded as well as they did.

Overall the singing was good and the acting very good. Ziyi Dai as Amina had all the notes but her tone had little variation and tended towards hardness so that she brought out little of the pathos of the piece. Nico Darmanin sang with style, although his high Cs were not something to savour.  Simon Shibambu's well cushioned baritone dealt well with Rudolfo and Ellie Neate was a fetching and lively Lisa, a role highlighted here more than in most productions. Jacob Bettinelli impressed in the small part of Alessio. One very definite improvement was in the size and quality of the chorus which, together with a nicely paced performance from the orchestra under Adrian Kelly, underpinned a very enjoyable musical evening even if not quite of the first rank.

The "buts" came, as all too often, in the production. For some reason Harry Fehr and his team set the opera in a factory canteen around the 1960s by the look of the costumes. A canopy over the canteen counter together with a strategically placed step ladder provided a rather tame sleep walking scene.  The production's modernity was signalled by Teresa producing a pair of Lisa's panties rather than the traditional scarf or handkerchief to show that she had been to Rodolfo's room.

One has to doubt whether a quasi realistic setting can ever truly illuminate this opera but the main problem was that it was all rather dreary and did little to complement or respond to the beauty of the music. However, within its chosen limits, it was consistent and well realised.

pic

To round off the opera, after an initial "Ah, non giunge" directed at Elvino, Amina's repeats were directed at Lisa and the opera ended with them running off together to the church. While to modern eyes one might take the view that Elvino is rather more tied up with his own reputation than his love for Amina or Lisa, the opera's setting in the 1960s and the previous actions in the opera in no way led up to it, even if one felt justified in going against the traditional interpretation and the musical logic. It just seemed to be aimed at ending with a cheap laugh.

Both this year's and last year's productions lead one to feel that Buxton's return to staging bel canto opera has still some way to go to achieve that easy affinity that they cultivated under Andrew Greenwood. 

 

Photos by Genevieve Girling, courtesy of Buxton International Festival

pic

Lisa and Alessio

 

pic

Elvino and Amina

 

pic

Count Rodolfo and Amina

 

pic

Amina

 

pic

Lisa
(the canopy and stepladder for the sleep walking scene can be seen in the background)

 

pic

A distraught Amina