Donizetti's
La Favourite, Chiara e Serafina
and L’aio nell’imbarazzo
Donizetti Festival, Bergamo, 2022
John Harris,
December 2022
Photographs by
Gianfranco Rota, courtesy of the Donizetti
Festival
November - so the Donizetti Opera Festival in
Bergamo to enjoy once again…..The pattern now
seems set - three operas with two in the
restored Donizetti Opera House in town, the
middle one in the lovely Teatro Sociale in Citta
Alta, the medieval gem surrounded by World
Heritage Site Venetian Walls.

The main opera house (John Harris)
This year we had La Favourite (Paris;
December 1840 ), Chiara e Serafina (La
Scala; October 1822 ) and L’aio
nell’imbarazzo (Rome; February 1824 ) -
and the stage productions gave plenty to
consider …... With film, music is deployed to
reinforce and support the visual presentation
but with opera it is not unreasonable to expect
the reverse to be the case - if the stage
production becomes a distraction then the music
is not served and all the performances this year
were a real test for the audience of which I was
a part; as a further distraction, the sur-titles
attempted to give a complete translation of the
full libretto so they were in constant full
flight.
La Favourite had Javier Camarena,
Annalisa Stroppa, and Florian Sempey in the
leading roles with bass Evgeny Stravinsky in
particularly fine voice. The stage production
was described as ‘offer(ing) an essential
feminine perspective’ with the full ballet
being a really hard test…As an early success (
based on a reworking of L'Ange de Nisida
) the opera did not maintain a place in the
repertoire although there were occasional
revivals with major singers, quite a number of
recordings, and Toscanini conducted a centenary
performance in Bergamo.
Chiara e Serafina ( or The Pirates )
was led by Pietro Spagnoli in the buffo role
supported by La Scala Academy students with
Greta Doveri and Fan Zhou in the title roles. It
is a rarity to have a performance to hear and
the stage production was aimed at reflecting
Italian 1950s and 1960s variety shows and for
the English the false noses and false chins and
costumes were reminiscent of pantomime......you
will get the idea.
L’aio nell’imbarazzo, a significant
early opera buffa which was the first of his
operas to be performed outside Italy ( also
known as Don Gregorio ) had Alex Esposito in the
tutor role with the two sons sung by Francesco
Lucii and Lorenzo Martelli and Gilda by Marilena
Rita. It disappeared until a Bergamo production
in 1959 and then Wexford in 1973 led to some
revivals. Again there was a stage production
which dominated the performance with mobile
platforms constantly on the move throughout -
explanation references were to ‘the virtual
reality of the web’....
The Festival benefits from singers who appear in
the international opera houses including the
Met. We hear, too, young singers. They are
there to bring the music of Donizetti to life -
and that is what the audience have come to
enjoy. The two opera houses are wonderful
buildings. You will note the absence of
appreciative comment about the stage productions
- the music of Donizetti is paramount.....
As ever the Festival was a most enjoyable
experience in this city which it is a joy to
visit. Sara at the the box office of the
Fondazione Teatro Donizetti could not be more
helpful - her friendliness and kindness typifies
our experience of the local residents and
students.
Some examples below from the productions.
Photographs by Gianfranco Rota
La Favourite




Chiara e Serafina




L’aio
nell’imbarazzo




|